I believe the whole thing will be streamed live online, and it will certainly be recorded for posterity. The existence of god in light of contemporary cosmology. Sean carroll debates william lane craig the world of animals. On this channel you will find fulllength talks, lectures, and debates of philosopher and theologian dr. They say that carroll destroyed craig, but of course they said the same thing about hitchens. Thoughts on william lane craig, and his debates with sam. Well, the update is that the full recording is now available, and so here it is below or here oh and before you leap in, you may want to consider the.
Structured as a debate, the 2014 greerheard forum focused on the issue of god and cosmology and its impact on life and selfunderstanding. Well, the much anticipated debate between caltech cosmologist sean carroll and theologian william lane craig happened this weekend in new orleans and was at least to me as enjoyable as expected. Sean carrolls reflections on his debate with william lane craig. Who won the debate between william lane craig and sean. But craig s answer misses something very important. Science, philosophy, and the sean carroll debate reasonable faith video.
Craig is on the offensive, organized, and very well stated. Part 1 of 9 sam harris vs william lane craig debate. Carroll was as good of a speaker as craig in terms of style. William lane craig professor of philosophy at the talbot school of theology has set out in the latest edition of philosophy now his eight best arguments for the existence of god nonpaywall access here. God and cosmology william lane craig and sean carroll. William lane craig philosopher and christian apologist had a debate about this topic.
Sean carroll last week i posted my initial thoughts after watching the craig v. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. Im going to pretend to be a physicist and use sciencey words to retrofit modern cosmology to my primitive, crude, vague theistic sensibilities, and religion explains the universe better than physics because i can make up any ol shit i want. Why do atheists almost always lose to william lane craig. There was only one of those few that i felt he unequivocally won. University of notre dame, april 7, 2011 philosopher and scholar dr.
William lane craig and sean carroll god and cosmology 2014. I was even surprised that craig showedup after carrols opening speech. William lane craig vs shelly kagan debate duration. D ont feel embarrassed if youve never heard of william lane craig. And then theres an exercise of this causal power, um, that brings the universe into existence. William lane craig debate posted on january 28, 2014 by sean carroll last week i participated in a dialogue with princeton philosopher hans halvorson. Craig has been honing his debate skills literally since high school. This is by far one of the most entertaining debate ive ever seen wlc compete in, simply because sean carroll thoroughly demolished him. I blogged about the sean carroll vs william lane craig debate a few days ago, and alas that was only impressions from notes. William lane craig is an excellent speaker too bad his completely wrong. Please help support the blogging efforts of a tippling philosopher.
Sean carroll debates william lane craig on cosmology and gods existence. Remember, it was on the existence of god, and all dr. I ask the questions and try to stay out of the way on this podcast, and not say anything dumb, and learn along with you. William lane craig cited a paper not empirical evidence, but a theoretical argument that. William lane craig and sean carroll in dialoge download online. William lane craig and sean carroll in dialoge download full ebook. A blog entry by an atheist cosmologist sean carroll states that william lane craig is a philosopher and theologian the word apologist only. Craig argued that carrolls own model fell victim to the boltzmann brain problem.
William lane craig and sean carroll debate tactical faith. A facebook page to encourage leading atheist richard dawkins to debate the leading christian apologist, william lane craig. That is, let the audience think about whether a goodsounding and confidentlyspoken. Richard dawkins debate william lane craig home facebook. The refusal of richard dawkins to debate william lane craig has attracted criticism from other atheists, one of whom has said it is apt to be interpreted as cowardice dawkins refuses goddebate. William lane craig debates truth according to scripture. The existence of god in light of contemporary cosmology 09. William lane craig and sean carroll in dialogue greerheard lectures grearheard lectures sean carroll, william lane craig, robert b. Craig has updated and defended the kalam cosmological argument for the existence of god. Why i refuse to debate with william lane craig richard. Transcript science, philosophy, and the sean carroll debate. Godcosmology debate videos posted on february 27, 2014 by sean carroll here is the video from my debate with william lane craig at the 2014 greerheard forum. Christian philosopher william lane craig and atheist cosmologist sean carroll presented their views before a packed crowd of more than nine hundred people.
Sean carroll debates william lane craig on cosmology and. William lane craig is research professor of philosophy at talbot school of theology and professor of philosophy at houston baptist university. Sam harris is the foundation of morality natural or supernatural. On friday, february 21st, 2014, philosopher and theologian, dr william lane craig, was invited by the greer heard forum to debate dr sean. Andrew at evaluating christianity has put up some excellent posts of advice on how to debate william lane craig one, two, three, four, five. The greerheard pointcounterpoint forum in faith and culture is a program of new orleans baptist theological seminary.
And he has consistently declined, always with specious excuseswhich are all the more galling given that they are much the same excuses dawkins gave for not debating craig, which craig then mocked, not at all grasping the irony. William lane craig or wlc as we call him in the business is of course a very wellknown figure, largely for his many public debates, on theismatheism as well as on various other specific theological issues. Sean carroll vs william lane craig debate available. William lane craig born august 23, 1949 is an american analytic philosopher and christian. William lane craig and sean carroll god and cosmology 2014 greer heard forum duration. Craig from the beginning is on fire and hitchens seems very passive. How to debate wlc january 27, 2014 by lukebarnes as i explained in my last post, im expecting good things from the upcoming. Craigs exciting debates with prominent philosophers, scientists, and biblical scholars on the truth. William lane craigs eight specialpleading arguments for. Religious epistemology mp3 audio by william lane craig. Ahmed had to do was demonstrate enough doubt to abstain from belief, and show how wlcs arguments did not remove that doubt. Although, in my view, craig ably handled carrolls objections and offered his own solid arguments, which carroll failed to refute.
William lane craig and sean carroll in dialogue greerheard lectures grearheard lectures. Craigs theological interests are in historical jesus studies and philosophical theology, and his philosophical work focuses primarily on philosophy of religion, but also on metaphysics and philosophy of time. The reason craig wins all his debates with atheists is not because his arguments are sound, but because he is a masterful debater. The veritas forum, ohio state university, usa february 2016.
Here is the video from my debate with william lane craig at the 2014 greer heard forum. Sean carrolls reflections on his debate with william lane. Hitchens just seems to shrug his shoulders a lot and doesnt answer many of the questions put to him. There are two people who have been asking noted christian apologist william lane craig to debate them for years. Transcript, video, carrolls postdebate reflections, craigs. William lane craig in a recent debate with lawrence krauss gives us an answer. How to debate william lane craig common sense atheism. These and more are discussed in a critical response to the debate with sean carroll. William lane craig born august 23, 1949 is an american analytic philosopher and christian theologian. As for the notre dame debate, many commenters on the video including harris fans felt craig did a better job by staying on the topic of the debate and addressing harris arguments claim. Now, william lane craigs defence of the kalam cosmological argument was subjected to piercing criticism by sean carroll in their recent debate about god and cosmology. William lane craig and sean carroll in dialogue greer heard.
William lane craig and sean carroll god and cosmology. Thoughts on william lane craig, and his debates with sam harris. Craig s exciting debates with prominent philosophers, scientists, and biblical scholars on the truth claims of biblical christianity. Debate videos and transcripts media reasonable faith. Why i refuse to debate with william lane craig richard dawkins. I would say that god exists timelessly with the intention that a physical world exist.
Watch the debate on youtube or check out the book based on the event, god and cosmology. Craig does come off pretentious, stopping short of declaring himself the winner, but in reality he clearly is. The rigorous debate was concluded by a lengthy question and answer period with the audience. On friday, february 21st, 2014, philosopher and theologian, dr william lane craig, was invited by the greer heard forum to debate dr sean carroll, an atheist theoretical physicist. William lane craig is an american christian apologist, analytic philosopher and theologian. The event was hosted by the greerheard forum and consisted of a formal. Craig was there to produce evidence for the existense of god from cosmology, carroll was there to rebutt. William lane craig debates atheist sam harris author of bestsellers like end of faith, letter to a christian nation, and the moral landscape. William lane craigarchive 10 jump to navigation jump to search. Carroll, craig, causes and explanations saints and sceptics.
The atheists are all gaga over carrolls performance in this debate. And thats not just to win the debate, but it goes to carrolls goal of giving the audience something to think about. Science, philosophy, and the sean carroll debate reasonable. I did not watch this and was under the assumption that i could catch it the next day on youtube but no, the youtube live stream went private. He holds faculty positions at talbot school of theology biola university and houston baptist university. That was the one he had with sam harris a few years ago. Dr william lane craig vs dr sean carroll, an atheist theoretical physicist. Very easy to listen to, very quick on his feet, very civil. Recently, sean carroll cosmologist and atheist, whom i have met a couple times at physics events and st. Sean carroll vs william lane craig debate available a.
450 1282 1113 417 1455 1164 1353 72 947 950 1054 1138 1267 405 833 273 319 1020 534 1075 1273 1074 812 1304 574 923 110 741 349 1425 617 1343 1168 1268